Ohio State vs. Oklahoma: Argue right here for who deserves Playoff spot extra | NCAA Soccer


The ultimate Faculty Soccer Playoff pairings might be selected Sunday, however the largest argument has already began in earnest.

Will No. 5 Oklahoma or No. 6 Ohio State take the final spot within the four-team Playoff?

MORE: Sporting Information Week 14 Energy Rankings

After all, that jumps to a conclusion. No. 5 Oklahoma meets No. 9 Texas within the Massive 12 championship at midday ET on Saturday. The Buckeyes play No. 21 Northwestern within the Massive Ten championship recreation at eight p.m. that night time.  

This state of affairs assumes No. 1 Alabama knocks off No. Four Georgia within the SEC championship recreation, No. 2 Clemson beats Pitt within the ACC championship recreation and each the Sooners and Buckeyes win their respective title video games.

A take a look at each groups’ Playoff resumes, and which one has the perfect wager to make the Playoff: 

Case file   

Each are powerful blue bloods in Energy 5 conferences, and every made the Playoff the final two seasons, partially, due to the energy of a head-to-head victory towards the opposite. One crew cannot merely out-brand the opposite one, particularly since each groups have high-flying offenses with Heisman Trophy-contending quarterbacks on the helm.

Oklahoma, led by coach Lincoln Riley and quarterback Kyler Murray, leads the FBS with 50.Three factors per recreation. Ohio State, led by coach City Meyer and quarterback Dwayne Haskins, ranks seventh with 43.Three factors per recreation.  

Let’s break down the case for and towards every crew.  

Oklahoma’s argument 

The offense is not simply good; it is well-rounded and might be unstoppable. The Sooners and Buckeyes are No. 1 and No. 2 in complete offense, however Oklahoma ranks within the high 10 in passing offense and dashing offense:  

Faculty Whole Cross Rush
Oklahoma 583.7 319.4 264.3
Ohio State 543.9 356.0 187.9

The Sooners misplaced one recreation this season to Texas — a 48-45 shootout in a rivalry contest — however Oklahoma can appropriate that mistake towards the Longhorns within the Massive 12 championship recreation. The Sooner took care of enterprise in street wins at Iowa State and West Virginia, and a victory towards Texas would add a top-10 victory.

Ohio State’s argument

Ohio State dominated the highest protection within the nation in a 62-39 victory towards Michigan on Saturday. Oklahoma would not have a victory higher than that. The Buckeyes gained the Massive Ten East for the second consecutive season, together with wins at Penn State and Michigan State.

Ohio State managed that regardless of a three-game suspension for City Meyer and the lack of defensive finish Nick Bosa, who was thought-about the perfect participant within the nation on the time. If it actually comes right down to “who you play,” then Ohio State has a wonderful case. Whenever you take a look at Oklahoma, you already know what to consider probably the most. Do we now have to say it once more?  

The protection.

MORE: OSU reminds committee it is Playoff materials

Rebuttal towards Oklahoma  

Oklahoma fired its defensive coordinator after the loss to Texas, and the Sooners have given up 40 or extra factors in every of their final 4 video games, not together with that loss to Texas.

The Sooners are 104th in complete protection (449.0 ypg), which is far worse than Ohio State (399.5), which ranks 63rd. How a lot of a reward does that fashion of play deserve?

Rebuttal towards Ohio State 

Ohio State misplaced 49-20 at Purdue on Oct. 20, a loss that the committee merely cannot overlook. The Buckeyes beat beleaguered Maryland 52-51 and  Nebraska 31-26, groups which have mixed to go 9-15. The win towards Michigan is spectacular, however any notion that this crew is head-and-shoulders above the Sooners merely is not true.   

About these defenses. Are they actually that completely different? Chalk Oklahoma’s go protection distinction as much as taking part in towards higher quarterbacks, too.

Staff Whole Cross Rush
Ohio State 398.9 237.6 161.3
Oklahoma 449.0 286.6 162.4

MORE: Oklahoma has worthwhile second probability vs. Texas

Oklahoma closing assertion

Admit it, you wish to see Tua Tagovailoa and Kyler Murray in Miami. Do we have to plant a flag to make our level?  

Ohio State closing assertion

Nick Saban vs. City Meyer, individuals. Ohio State is the one crew with sufficient expertise on each side of the ball, aside from Clemson, that may entertain beating Alabama.  


A number of publications will assault this query of their closing spherical of bowl projections, and Sporting Information went with the Buckeyes — however it’s a toss-up.

That is to not say Oklahoma cannot win the argument, however it is going to be very laborious to show down the Buckeyes on this state of affairs. The one factor giving us pause is the Tua-Kyler issue, however head-to-head we predict Ohio State would beat Oklahoma. We have heard the phrase “4 best groups” sufficient to imagine the committee could possibly be swayed in that path.

Supply hyperlink